Every plumber who wants more work from Google ends up with the same question: pay for clicks now, or invest in ranking for free later? The honest answer depends on your town, your jobs and how soon you need the phone to ring. Here is how the two compare.
How each one works
Google Ads (pay per click, or PPC) shows your advert at the top of the results for the searches you choose, such as “emergency plumber [town]”. You pay each time someone clicks. Your ad appears as soon as the campaign goes live and disappears when you stop paying.
SEO (search engine optimisation) earns your place in the Map Pack and the normal results below the ads. You don’t pay per click. Instead you invest in your Google Business Profile, your service pages, reviews and local signals, and the visibility builds over months.
There is a third option for some trades: Local Services Ads, which appear above the normal ads and charge per lead rather than per click. Plumbers are among the UK trades Google accepts, subject to checks; see Google’s Local Services Ads page for eligibility in your area.
Side by side
| Google Ads | SEO | |
|---|---|---|
| How fast | Same day | Weeks for the profile, months for organic rankings |
| What you pay | Per click, every click | A monthly fee for the work, no per-click cost |
| When you stop | Calls from ads stop straight away | Visibility fades slowly if left alone |
| Best for | Filling the diary now, testing which jobs sell | Steady enquiries you don’t pay per click for |
| Main risk | Paying for clicks that never become jobs | Waiting for results in a very contested town |
When Google Ads pays back first
Ads make most sense when:
- you need calls this month, for example after starting out or moving area;
- you work in a busy town where ranking for emergency terms will take a long time;
- you want to test which jobs bring the best return before building pages for them;
- you are pushing high-value work such as boiler installs, where one won job covers a lot of clicks. Multi-van firms often run both on installs; see SEO for plumbing companies.
The common money-wasters are broad keywords, no negative keywords and a landing page that buries the phone number. Mudfish’s guide to Google Ads for plumbers covers setting up a campaign properly. (Mudfish is run by the same team as this site.)
Ads are a tap: brilliant when it’s running, and nothing comes out the moment you turn it off.
When SEO pays back better
SEO tends to win over a longer stretch when:
- you plan to work the same patch for years;
- most of your work is urgent local searches, where the Map Pack takes the bulk of the calls (our guide to local SEO for plumbers explains how it picks);
- you want enquiries that land on your phone only, rather than paying per click or per lead;
- your competitors haven’t done much with their profiles and websites yet, which is still common in many towns.
Our plumbing SEO service sets out what that work involves month by month, and our pricing is published, so you can weigh it against an ad budget.
Working out which pays back for you
You don’t need a spreadsheet to start. For each channel, track three numbers every month:
- What you spent (ad spend, or the SEO fee).
- How many enquiries it brought in.
- How many became jobs, and roughly what they were worth.
Divide spend by jobs won to get a cost per won job for each. Within a few months the numbers usually make the decision for you.
Comparing SEO and ads on clicks alone is like pricing a boiler on the box. Look at what’s fitted and paid for.
Running both
For many plumbing firms the sensible plan is both, for a while. Ads cover emergency searches and installs while SEO builds; as your Map Pack and organic positions start bringing in steady calls, you can trim ad spend on the searches you already win for free. Our guide to emergency plumber SEO covers the free side of emergency visibility, and what SEO costs a plumber breaks down the monthly fee.
The straight answer
If you need the phone to ring next week, start with ads. If you plan to be in the same patch in three years, start SEO now. If you’re not sure which your town needs, ring SEO for Plumbers: on the 20-minute call we look live at who holds your searches, and if ads are the better first spend, we’ll tell you.